Press Play Again: 2 Roommates, 1 Remote
Welcome to Press Play Again: 2 Roommates, 1 Remote - the rewatch and pop culture catch-up podcast where two former college roommates in their 30s revisit the shows and movies that shaped them, plus dive into today's must-watch series. From nostalgic teen dramas and cult-favorite rom-coms to buzzy new releases, we hit play on everything we can't stop talking about. Grab a snack, get comfy, and join us on the couch as we rewatch, debate, and laugh through old favorites and new obsessions - all with one remote and a lot of opinions.
Episodes
39 episodes
Was This Show Better Than We Remember? (Dawson’s Creek 2x13)
Season 2, Episode 13 brings everything a little closer to the surface—and makes it harder than ever for anyone to pretend they don’t feel what they’re feeling.In this episode, we break down the emotional tension that’s been building and ...
•
56:09
Why Did Everyone Enable Abby? (Dawson’s Creek 2x12)
Season 2, Episode 12 leans fully into the emotional tension—and makes it clear that nothing in Capeside is staying simple.In this episode, we break down how everything feels just a little more heightened: conversations carry more weight,...
•
50:58
Media Catch Up (BONUS)
Quick, chaotic, and straight to the point - this bonus episode is our media catch up. We're talking about everything we've been watching, listening to, and accidentally falling into lately, from comfort rewatches to new finds (and a few "why di...
•
16:35
Is This Episode Iconic or Just Messy? (Dawson’s Creek 2x11)
Season 2, Episode 11 turns the emotional volume up just a little higher—and suddenly the cracks everyone’s been ignoring are a lot harder to overlook.In this episode, we unpack the growing tension between expectations and reality as Daw...
•
51:13
Is This the Worst TV Couple Ever?? (Dawson's Creek 2x10)
Season 2, Episode 10 reminds us that in Capeside, even the quieter moments come with emotional consequences.In this episode, we break down the shifting dynamics between Dawson, Joey, and the rest of the group as expectations, jealousy, ...
•
43:57
Background Noise Check In
We’re back with a quick bonus episode where we catch up on everything we’ve been watching, listening to, and randomly consuming lately. From comfort rewatches to new discoveries (and a few questionable choices), we’re sharing the highlights of ...
•
15:20
Something New is Coming....
I WROTE AN EBOOK!!!On March 15 you can purchase and download immediately a new guided reflection journal! Inspired by the pacing and drama of your favorite TV show, this journal turns your life into a story - from the pilot episode to th...
•
1:00
Why Did No One Stop This From Happening? (Dawson’s Creek 2x9)
Season 2, Episode 9 raises the emotional stakes—and dares the show to go where it’s been hinting all along.In this episode, we unpack heightened tension, complicated loyalties, and the moments that quietly redraw relationship lines. Daws...
•
56:13
Did This Couple Ever Have Chemistry? (Dawson’s Creek 2x8)
Season 2, Episode 8 shifts the emotional temperature in Capeside—and suddenly, everything feels a little less predictable.In this episode, we break down how new dynamics start to form while old expectations quietly fall apart. Dawson is ...
•
1:03:07
Why Does This Hit So Differently Now? (Dawson’s Creek 2x7)
Season 2, Episode 7 raises the emotional stakes and proves that avoidance has a shelf life.In this episode, we break down how unspoken feelings start surfacing in ways that are impossible to ignore. Joey is pulled between who she’s been ...
•
48:02
Was This Breakup Avoidable? (Dawson’s Creek 2x6)
Season 2, Episode 6 takes a sharp turn toward honesty—and not everyone is prepared for what that actually requires.In this episode, we unpack the growing emotional tension that can no longer be brushed off as “miscommunication...
•
1:08:24
This Could’ve Been an Email… But It’s a Podcast Instead.
In this bonus episode, we’re doing a quick check-in on everything we consumed this week—TV shows, movies, podcasts, random internet finds, and whatever else ended up as background noise while we lived our lives.No deep dives, no spoiler...
•
14:54
When did we turn on Mitch? (Dawson’s Creek 2x5)
Season 2, Episode 5 leans hard into discomfort—and forces these characters to sit with feelings they’ve been carefully avoiding.In this episode, we break down the growing emotional imbalance between Dawson and Joey, the way expectations...
•
1:10:22
Is this supposed to be romantic? (Dawson's Creek 2x4)
Season 2, Episode 4 pushes everything another step forward… whether these characters are ready or not.In this episode, we unpack the emotional fallout that’s no longer simmering quietly under the surface. Dawson is struggling with expec...
•
1:46:34
Was this episode iconic or just messy? (Dawson’s Creek 2x3)
Season 2, Episode 3 turns up the tension in Capeside, and suddenly everyone’s emotions are right on the surface… whether they’re ready for that or not.In this episode, we break down the growing cracks in Dawson and Joey’s attempts to mov...
•
1:05:11
Was Dawson the Villian All Along? (Dawson’s Creek 2x2)
Season 2, Episode 2 wastes no time reminding us that the fallout from last season is still very much alive in Capeside.In this episode, we dig into the emotional aftershocks of Dawson and Joey’s “new normal”, Pacey’s q...
•
1:12:56
Was this the moment everything changed?? (Dawson's Creek 2x1) PART 2
Season 2 kicks off with a lot to unpack. Dawson's Creek returns after the cliffhanger of the season one finale and everyone is very much AWKWARD!In this episode, we break down the Dawson and Joey kiss, Pacey's new hair, new characters, a...
•
1:05:05
Was this the moment everything changed?? (Dawson's Creek 2x1)
Season 2 kicks off with a lot to unpack. Dawson's Creek returns after the cliffhanger of the season one finale and everyone is very much AWKWARD!In this episode, we break down the Dawson and Joey kiss, Pacey's new hair, new characters, a...
•
1:12:22
Christmas Movie #3 "A Boyfriend for Christmas"
This is Anna's favorite Christmas movie of all time! From beginning to end it brings a wave of nostalgia and butterflies every single time! If you've never watched it, do yourself a favor and catch up on it and then listen to this episode!<...
•
13:51
Press Play Again with Alice Scott part 2
If you need a rundown of what to watch and what not to watch this Christmas season listen to this episode! It’s full of chaos and laughter but good info too! We reminisce and go deep with family traditions and gifts from Christmases past. You d...
•
1:32:50
Christmas Movie #2 “Christmas Comes Home” + Alice Scott
On this week's episode I have a very special guest joining me who just so happens to have some incredible insight and experience with the movie we watched. Buckle up because there's guaranteed laughter, maybe some tears, and just a little bit o...
•
30:14
Christmas Movie #1 "A Christmas in Tennessee"
We're kicking off our December movie lineup with "A Christmas in Tennessee - the small-town holiday romance that has everything: a struggling bakery, a big-city developer with an agenda, a town that apparently runs on charm and free cookies, an...
•
36:47
Dawson's Creek 1x13 "Decisions"
The Season 1 finale hits hard. Joey faces a massive decision that forces her to confront what she really wants - and who she really wants. Dawson finally gets a taste of clarity (or as close as Dawson can get), while Jen deals with an emotional...
•
45:20